Judy's Punishment

The only thing anyone says was "Hold Still!" Who the hell was he talking to? Why bother saying anything at all if you're only gonna say something meaningless?

Regarding the animation, she seems incredibly resilient. She doesn't seem to be suffering from strangulation at all. And despite the extreme brutality of the punches, and the obvious intention to cause her as much suffering as possible, she isn't even crying at all. She not even suffering more than she might be during a difficult session at the gym. Women cry over everything, so I'd say her lack of tears is the specific detail I find most questionable. It's a stunning detail to get wrong.

Beating someone while they're hanging by the neck makes no sense. What is the point?

Do you want her to suffer? Then bind her to a chair and beat her for as long as you want.
Do you want to kill her or not? Hanging is a "humane" way to execute someone. It's not usually the method chosen by a sadist. Cruelly beating a bound prisoner is a technique for getting information from an enemy. But this guy doesn't ask any questions. How will he know when he's done?

It's funny that he goes and grabs a bat after beating her with his fists for so long. It's like he admits she's too strong for him to hurt with his fits, so he thinks maybe a bat will work.